Claims Fraud Red Flags for Claims Handlers
A practical list of insurance fraud red flags for claims handlers across property, motor, injury and travel claims, and how to turn them into a referral.
Insurance fraud red flags for a claims handler are facts in the file that do not fit together: a story that changes, paperwork that looks too tidy, a loss that is bigger than the evidence supports. A red flag is a reason to look closer. It is never proof. Your job is to notice, record and refer, not to decide that a customer is lying.
This article gives you the indicators to watch in the common claim types and a simple way to turn them into a referral. For the full picture of fraud in insurance, start with the frontline guide to insurance fraud detection.
Opportunistic versus premeditated
Most claims fraud is not a master plan. It is a normal claim with a little added.
- Opportunistic. A real loss, then padding: a phone added to a burglary list, a repair priced higher, an old scratch included in a new accident.
- Premeditated. The loss itself is planned or invented: a staged crash, a fake theft, a fire that was set.
You deal with them differently. Opportunistic padding is often settled by asking for proof of the extra items. Premeditated fraud needs a referral to your fraud team. If you are not sure, the safe step is to refer and let the specialists decide.
Indicators of a staged incident
Look at the event, not the person.
- The incident happened soon after the policy started or the cover increased.
- It happened at night, in a quiet place, with no witnesses and no camera.
- The people involved know each other, but say they do not.
- The damage does not match the description, for example low-speed damage described as a major crash.
- Everyone has the same repairer, the same solicitor or the same story in nearly the same words.
One of these means little. Several together deserve attention.
Inflated losses and invented contents
On property claims, the contents list is where padding hides.
- Items listed without receipts, photos or serial numbers
- Receipts that look alike, are all dated close together or come from a shop that does not seem to exist
- Items that are rare or valuable for a customer whose life does not match them
- A list that grows each time you speak to the customer
- A claim for old goods priced as if they were bought yesterday
Ask for evidence in a neutral way: "To process this, I need proof of ownership for each item. A photo, a receipt or a bank statement all help." A genuine customer finds something. A fraudulent one often finds excuses.
Injuries that do not match the incident
On injury claims, compare the injury with the event.
- Severe injury after a very slight impact
- Symptoms that appear days later and grow without clear medical notes
- A claimant who is described as unable to move but is seen active
- Many people in one vehicle all claiming for similar injuries
You are not a doctor. Do not judge the medical side. Describe what does not match and pass it to the people who can assess it. Follow your employer's procedure for medical information.
Example: a burglary claim with receipts all dated the same week
Say a customer, Ms Castellanos, reports a burglary and claims for a television, a laptop, a camera, two watches and a coat. She sends receipts for all six items. You notice that every receipt is dated in the same week, three weeks before the burglary, and they are from five different shops. The policy started two months ago. No serial numbers are given.
None of this proves anything. People do buy several items in a short time. But the pattern is unusual: a recent policy, a recent burst of purchases, no serial numbers.
What you do: you ask Ms Castellanos for bank or card statements showing the purchases. You do not say you think she is lying. You write the facts in the file: the dates, the shops, what was asked and the answer. If the statements do not support the receipts, or she cannot provide them, you refer the file to the fraud team. You do not refuse the claim yourself.
When this does not work: one indicator is never proof
People have bad luck, bad memory and bad paperwork. A customer in shock may get a date wrong. A real thief may take things the customer cannot prove they own. A claimant with a real injury may have a good day.
So never treat a single indicator as the answer. And never let a red flag turn your tone cold. If you accuse an honest customer, you harm them and you harm the insurer. Stay polite, stay curious, keep asking for the same evidence you would ask from anyone. Our article on interviewing a claimant without accusing them shows how.
Also watch for groups. If the same names, addresses, phone numbers or repairers keep appearing across claims, you may be seeing a network. See how to spot an organised insurance fraud ring.
Turning indicators into a referral
A good referral is short and factual. Use this order:
- The claim. Number, type, date of loss, amount.
- The indicators. A list, one line each, with where you saw it.
- What you asked and what came back. Dates and words.
- What you have not done. For example: no decision made, customer not told of the referral.
- Your name and the date.
Leave out opinions like "he is clearly lying". Write "the receipts are all dated the same week; the customer could not provide statements". Your employer's procedure and local rules set what you must do next and who must be told.
Learn this in five minutes
The track "Spotting Staged and Exaggerated Claims" covers opportunistic and planned fraud, staged incidents, inflated contents, injuries that do not match and how to write the referral. Each lesson takes five minutes and uses a claim you could have on your desk.
